We live in a true epistemological void, in which the truth is increasingly for sale.
That’s the backdrop against which Doge is doing its dirty business. Doge’s assault on expert agencies enjoys a depressing degree of popular support, but it’s not hard to understand why: so many of our expert agencies have staged high-profile demonstrations of their unfitness, without any consequences, that it’s easy to sell the story that these referees were all on the take.
They weren’t, of course. Most expert regulators – career civil servants – really care about their jobs. They want to make sure you can survive a trip to the grocery story rather than shitting your guts out with listeria or giardia, that your plane doesn’t collide with a military chopper, that your kids graduate school knowing more than how to pass a standardized test. The tragedy is that these honorable, skilled regulators’ commitment to your wellbeing isn’t enough to produce policies that actually safeguard your wellbeing.
Musk doesn’t want to fix the real, urgent problems with America’s administrative state: he wants to destroy it. He wants to fire the refs, because once you fire the refs, the game goes on – minus the rules. That’s a great way to win support for authoritarian projects: “The state won’t take care of you anymore (if it ever did, amirite?), but I will.”
So they’re firing the refs, and they’re transforming the game of “survive until tomorrow” into Calvinball, a “nomic” in which the rules are whatever someone insists they are:
Add new comment